I miss my mother lately. Or rather, I suppose, I miss the idea of my mother. I miss the mother that I know, deep down, she wanted to be. This longing started before the holidays when a coworker, coincidentally also named Sara, decided to bitch about having to spend the holidays with her mother. I was….annoyed.
Now I won’t claim that I never bitched about my mother. Quite the opposite, mostly likely, though rarely because who cared or wanted to listen? People found her to be an angel. But the conversation with my coworker touched a nerve I couldn’t quite put my finger on at the time and I found myself marred with unnamable emotions afterwards. It took me a few weeks, but I realized that what I was feeling was a weird sort of jealousy. My coworker Sara still had the opportunity to bitch about her family, where I did not. Her complaints, while they came from a different place than mine, still had value. I find myself in the weird place now of wanting to reach out and talk to the mother I always pictured mine wanting to be.
Moreover, I think I was sad that she could complain at all–because that is not a luxury I am afforded.
In elementary school, I had a friend named Alannah. Staying at her house was the highlight of my week–she had several horses, though the only one I can remember so many years later was her dark gray dappled pony named Roadrunner. He was the first pony I ever rode. I can still remember the horror in her voice as she stared down at me from his back the first time we hung out in her barn.
“You’ve….never ridden a horse?” The way she said it made it sound akin to me running over an animal with my bike. The pity that littered her gaze made me feel small.
“N-no,” I stammered, as I ran my fingers through his mane. I don’t know what I expected, exactly, but I took note of the fact that it felt absolutely nothing like the manes on my My Little Ponies.
“Oh my god. Do you want to?” She was already sliding off his back without waiting for my answer; I was on Roadrunner’s back before I fully comprehended what was occurring.
I had the time of my life that afternoon in the dusty barn. We took turns on Roadrunner’s back. Alannah was a good teacher for her age, and Roadrunner was an excellent pony. As the sun set and the dust settled in the ring, we braided Roadrunner’s shiny white-gray mane and giggled whenever we put a “girly-colored” bow as the end of one of the braids.
It was all fun and games until Alannah said, “You won’t ever have a pony, will you?” I read her tone as snotty, but as an adult I don’t think she was being intentionally mean–she just didn’t understand a world that wasn’t like her own. And she was right–I would never have a pony. But I couldn’t tell her that. I couldn’t say my feelings were hurt. I couldn’t say anything at all.
Late that night as I laid on the trundle bed in her room while she slept and I, quite simply, could not, I stared at her dresser and the photo there of Roadrunner, his mane braided and his show gear on. Before I could register I was doing something wrong, I crept to the dresser and snatched the photo, slipped it in my backpack, and left with it the next morning as if nothing was amiss. I could have a pony—at least in photo form.
The call from Alannah’s mother to my grandma went something like this:
“I believe Sara has taken something from my daughter’s room that does not belong to her.”
“Oh, Sara would never do that.”
“If that was my daughter, I would spank her until she could no longer sit.”
My grandma always did believe the best in me, even when I didn’t deserve it. And when she found out that I had, in fact, taken the photo, she sat me down on the couch to ask me why.
My little kid fingers clutched the edges of the picture frame as I held it out to her. “I wanted, for just one second, to pretend that he was mine.”
What I didn’t say: I wanted, for just one second, to pretend Alannah’s LIFE was mine. It goes without saying, but I’m not sure Alannah and I were friends after that day. I’d always had trouble keeping friends; always did something dumb that caused me to lose them. And most every relationship I’ve formed has been deeply superficial.
I can’t remember the last time I had a friend. I don’t mean the coworker I say hi to and shoot the shit with or the girl I occasionally text pet pictures to or even my roommate. Those are acquaintances. I mean a friend. I know so many wonderful people. But I don’t know how to make true friends. Someone I can talk to without being judged; someone I can tell everything and anything to; someone who won’t criticize me unless it’s deserved; someone I can actually count on. I don’t think that’s necessarily anyone’s fault. I just don’t know how to do it. It feels like I give and give but won’t get much if anything back, and then I get tired of giving and then things stop. I am not sure if I’m choosing the wrong people, if I’m giving up in the wrong place in the relationship, or what precisely breaks things. But I just finished Gypsy Rose Blanchard’s book and she actually sums up my friend experience quite well:
“The Disney Channel shows were always about friends and love and I had an idea of what a friend was, but I never had a long term friend…So many things about me were already so different than other kids…I was too complacent and complicit with the way things were. She (her mom) would get upset if I asked too many questions. So I just accepted the way things were.”
I attract people who want me around because I’m complacent and complicit. Because I do what I’m told. I know this because many have told me this. I know this because, when I do try and be myself, it feels like no one is listening. No one wants “my self” around.
I couldn’t have friends, couldn’t keep friends, because that was just the way things were. Acquaintances? Sure. But I wasn’t like everyone else. I couldn’t tell Alannah that, when she told me I would never have a pony the way she did and made me feel like I was less than, it made me jealous and hurt my feelings. There was no safe space that I knew of in which to say those words. I was not supposed to have feelings. Feelings got me shut in my room in the dark, got my head shoved into the filled tub, left me with bruises. I could not express them. I would not. It was better.
Until it wasn’t.
It’s destroyed every relationship I’ve had. My ideals of a “true” friendship, of one with give AND take and someone to count on will never exist, not for me. And I’m lonely, and I’m tired, and I’m growing older every year, on my own. It says something when I kept a therapist for years after her therapy stopped working just because she was someone I could talk to–even though I suspected after a while that she was no longer listening. That she became such a “friend” when she should have been a blank slate that I can no longer trust the process. That I thought of her as a friend when she was someone taking my money and nothing more.
I’m not sure where I’m going with this or what I was trying to say. Just that, I think, if there was ever anyone who should have been mine to talk to, it should have been my mother. It should have been, but it never was. These past weeks, since the holiday and beyond, where I’ve been wishing I had someone to talk to? I believe I’m missing the person I think she perhaps always wanted to be but absolutely never was. I’m missing what I never had.
And, at my core….I fear that my mother and I are the same. She too lived a life full of acquaintances—and that was all there was.